If Liberals Want to Help the Poor, They Should Focus on the Middle Class

What’s the surest sign that the economic crisis is finally lifting and normalcy is in sight? We’re back to arguing about how the middle class is doing over the long sweep of history since the 1980s: Have they been dragged down by stagnating wages, high-end inequality, economic insecurity, and a greater chance that economic mobility will take them downward than up? Or is the middle class doing OK?

This debate had been in hibernation for the last three years, while everyone except the top 1 percent took a beating. But it was reawakened recently, particularly by a series of papers and articles—including one in this magazine—by Scott Winship, a fellow at the Brookings Institution. Winship, joined by economist Tyler Cowen and others, throws cold water on an emerging consensus among economists and political scientists: that economic insecurity has increased for most families, that mobility has declined, and that rising economic inequality is related to slower (or more volatile) economic growth or to declining mobility. (The last theme was the subject of a brilliant speech by Alan Krueger, the chair of the Council on Economic Advisers, in January). Winship challenges some points in the data supporting these claims, and from those disputes, makes a larger claim: The middle class, he argues, “is doing just fine.”

I’m going to avoid the substance of this argument—much of which involves questions about methodology and interpretation of datasets that are well beyond me—because I’m interested in something else. What is really at stake in this debate? What makes technical disputes about inequality and mobility such a flashpoint? There must be some significant political or policy implications that follow from this argument, or it would be playing out in the American Economic Review rather than in this magazine and National Review.

According to Winship, the policy upshot of the debate is clear: He argues that overstating the economic difficulties of the middle class—or “pandering” to them, as he put it in TNR—is a dangerous way to achieve progressive policy goals; in particular, it will make it harder to achieve gains for those who really need help. Winship references the Harvard economist Benjamin Friedman’s book, The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth, to show that in tough times people are less likely to be generous toward the poor; Thomas Edsall’s new book, The Age of Austerity, would support that view as well. “Scaring the middle class,” Winship said at a recent discussion at the New America Foundation, “is not a good way to get support for the policies you want.”

But is it really the case that reassuring the middle class would make them more comfortable with supporting benefits for the poor? If the middle class were convinced it was doing just fine, would politicians then be more likely to bypass them and focus benefits on the worst-off? It seems unlikely. The truth is that the middle class will be the focus of political attention whether they are doing well or not, because there’s no politics other than middle-class politics. Consider that when a similar argument erupted in 2007, it was the Democratic think tank Third Way that played the glass-half-full role—but its policy recommendations still involved a Christmas stocking full of tax breaks to reward the aspirations of those happy middle class voters. Not since the New Deal, back when the vast majority of the country was objectively impoverished, has a political campaign of either the right or the left focused on the worst-off. Because most of the poor are either non-voters or reliable Democrats anyway (including low-income whites, outside of the South), successful politics always has to show that a candidate or a party at least “gets it” when it comes to the economic worries of the middle class. (Polling on the question of whether a candidate “cares about people like me” is a good measure—one on which Barack Obama does remarkably well.) Even John Edwards, who began his 2008 campaign with a stated focus on poverty, soon declared, “I’m not just talking about the rich and the poor. I’m talking about the very rich, and everybody else.” The most explicitly poverty-focused campaign in decades was, it turned out, really about the middle class.

Winship is certainly right that the impulse to scatter benefits widely across the upper reaches of the middle class can distract both resources and attention from the poor. And contrary to the old aphorism that “programs for poor people are poor programs,” there is evidence that the middle class will support spending on programs targeted mostly for low-income families, such as the State Children’s Health Insurance Program (S-CHIP). Trying to cut S-CHIP in 2006 was one of the most unpopular moves of the Republican Congress of that era.

But what Winship overlooks is that accurately recognizing the economic stresses facing most of the middle class can help create a sense of shared experience. With the unifying experience of the recession, low-income Americans are no longer “them”—they’re people who have suffered or worry about job loss, bankruptcy, foreclosure, or a costly health crisis just like many others. Studies that show how these experiences are shared by those in the bottom income quintile and the middle quintile—even if the circumstances are different in scale—can create a kind of cross-class solidarity that the country has not seen in many years.

Getting the data right matters, of course. But the implications of the result aren’t between a politics focused on the poor and one focused on the middle class. To the extent that many middle class families are experiencing insecurity, stagnating incomes, and doubts about mobility, it’s a chance to create a safety net that can support both the least-advantaged and those with a surer footing on the economic ladder. Perhaps it will allow us to reclaim the concept of “social insurance” in which we all share, even when we don’t happen to be taking advantage of the benefits at the moment. It could help us get away from thinking of welfare recipients or the unemployed as an entirely different category of people, deserving perhaps of charity but little more. If it’s true that the experiences of the middle class are different in scale but not in type from those of the poor, liberals are correct to sense the possibility of a new kind of social contract, one in which we think of the benefits and protections provided by government or by social insurance as a shared value.

Comments (8)Add a comment

Soon after above a couple of years of Windows 8 advancement, Microsoft Windows 8 company unveiled the new Place of Office 2010 , a better and user friendly version of Microsoft Office 2010 , that has all kinds of mixing new methods for Download Office 2010 cooperation, and an online ability Office 2010 Download in contrast to whatever often used in advance of. Buckling, storage, Microsoft Office 2010 Download visual presentation, surplus of e mail storage, powerful information understanding, creating successful suggestions with quite good quality of visual appeal with improved software are your favorite attributes that Microsoft Office 2011 has offered you with. Office 2010 Key compared to other peoples of several location manufactured swifter and controllable using the evolution of Microsoft office tools. The newest Microsoft Office Professional Plus 2007 program incorporates the improved popular Windows Office 2010 features of Concept, Succeed, Cheap Microsoft Office , Take on life, Writer, FrontPage and Power point. Outlook on life is even designed more Windows 7 Download Purchase suave and a lot more curbing featuring a Sociable Connection aspect for purchase microsoft office 2010 , LinkedIn or use the most popular Myspace.

There are a lot of blogs and articles out there on this topic, but you have captured another side of the subject. This is good content thank you for sharing it.
branson fishing charter

This is a well written article on this subject. I have been looking at starting a new business and this is valuable information to help me in my decision. Thank you.

This post has helped me to have another perspective. I am researching this topic for a paper I am writing. Your article provided me great insight of my topic.
right or wrong

Discount prada shoes are very important for virtually every male in her way of life. Prada America‘s Cup sneakers are essential for numerous requirements.This happens to most shoes prada men sneakers & prada high top sneaker that don’t offer any lace protection, though. Prada Shoulder Bags is every popular on the market .

Prada Purses many Prada specialist shoppers, could know the difference a duplicate prada Baggage from your prada Carriers because of its favorite songs produces, it is usually sincerely deafening while you extendable it again, a lot better in order to expansion it as well really you could possibly damage the whole case, only a bit of expansion can do, it produces any raucous special sound experience.Prada Patent Leather Shoes Men Black is made of black treated leather,it stout leather sole with skid-resistant function

Buying our cheap prada men casual shoes which are new arrivals provide latest styles and discount price for everyone.welcome to our prada shoes on sale online store to check the series styles and colors .

Timberland Shoes retail store on the net sales Saying Timberland Roll-Top Shoes intended for Adult males. Timberland Classic 2 Eye Mens Lug Sole Boat Shoes Throw Major Shoes intended for Adult males can market including Timberland Boots sizzling cakes with your web page at all times. A method not like another.Not previously know to persuade Roger Garcia several times, but Roger Garcia did not listen. When something far, she was not too Guan Dele. But now is not the same, Roger Timberland Mens 6-Inch Premium Boots at his side, he can every day, ‘monitor’ her.

The two sisters looked at each other Timberland Men’s Chukka Boots and smiled, although they saw once a year the surface, but they did not let the two sisters become alienated. On the contrary, this dim feeling of the relationship between the two sisters is getting better and better.

A Timberland outlets Factory Outlet is really a place for individuals who adore Timberland options but have quite limited purchasing budget. Timberland 14 inches Boot styles retailer cheap Timberland Boots on the web selling Proverb Timberland Roll-Top Boot styles regarding Guys.

To girls, nothing might be better than get one pair of beautiful shoes to be proud and attractive. These discount Louboutins available with nice and easygoing design. It is very easy to wear this discount 150mm Christian Louboutin Lady Peep in daily life. You deserve to have one or more pair for collection in this season.Christian louboutin daffodile are full of fashion taste, you can wear such shoes to party,also suitable for daily life.

Check out the main on your cheap red bottom 2012 shoes runner,Christian louboutin uk footwear is recognized in relation to red business! to aid you to put money on each and every phony will present a new burgandy particular. Christian Louboutin Bianca pumps are so practical that you all should buy one .You can dress yourself up by paying more attention to choose the right cheap louboutin shoes . Every woman fanaticizes of presenting herself in the best possible manner and to look really beautiful at Christian louboutin discount shoes.

As for my part, I think this discount newest Christian Louboutin Vicky 120mm Suede booty can apply to all kinds of occasion, allowing you to show characteristics and increased self-confidence freely. It was designed meticulously and specially for you. Buy one in our store with more discount and free shipping online. Just as christian louboutin pumps is really exclusive and sexy.

Anyone can save about 49% compared with the Moncler men vests, coats, jackets, and other types of providers, a contract of sale in the den. Moncler Women Long Down Coats is not accustomed anorak.The covering is fabricated of a affable, animationable abscondce bric that is baptize and wind abideant.The discount moncler winter coats are hotsale online.The moncler clothing are well know for fashion,ease and value.

Moncler Gene Women Jackets new could be the top-level brand in the down jacket fashion globe. It is a reality that Moncler jackets are prevailing amongst a lot of superstars, practically every single superstar in Hollywood owns 1 Moncler jacket .These Moncler Clairy Two Tone Down Jackets new are packed with perfect material which could by no suggests provide your entire body a cooler affect. via these coats, you have chance to go outside, when cold breeze will be blowing. In winters, you and your loved ones would like to pick having some fun.

These days, we are referring on the Women Moncler Coats Safran Quilted High Gloss with excellent overall performance and classy design and style. Men Moncler Jackets with attractive models, they go very well with jeans and shorts simply.People are satisied with moncler winter coats , it sells well in the cold winter in our store.